Should FIFA ban the Vuvuzela from World Cup 2010?

If you’ve watched the terrific Confederations Cup — and especially its thrilling USA:Brazil ending! — then you can’t have helped hearing the South African fans making noise with their traditional instruments of football mayhem, the vuvuzela.

They look like this:

The Vuvuzela is a noise maker found at South African soccer matches

The Vuvuzela is a noise maker found at South African soccer matches

A half-dozen fans having one of these, or even a lot of fans who blow on them to celebrate a goal or terrific defensively play is one thing, but as those of us that watched the FIFA Confederations Cup learned, the practice in South Africa seems to be to keep a continuous drone of vuvuzela going throughout the match.

And we’re not talking about twenty or thirty people in the stadium, we’re talking about hundreds, if not thousands, of locals keeping a deafening racket during the entire match.

Players have complained, coaches have complained, broadcast personnel have complained, but FIFA, so far, has said that it would allow vuvuzela’s in the World Cup 2010 stadiums and would allow South Africans to use them to mark their enjoyment and appreciation of the game.

I wish they wouldn’t. I found the constant clamor to be most distracting and annoying, and it even got in the way of being able to hear the crowd reaction to terrific plays or bad calls by referees both.

Maybe it’s time for the South African fans to learn some chants?

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Posted under 2010 World Cup

  • didimatso
    I agree, let us not judge, it feels like people are hoping for the WC to be a disaster, lets live & let live. I think change is good in life nomatter what form it comes in.

    after all, it is all for the love of the game, not country. I think south africa will host well & I am personally counting days to the kick-off, I cant waint & i think it will be marvellous.
  • karenlotter
    Anyone who has ever attended a soccer match in South Africa will tell you that the Sound of the Vuvuzelas is part of the spirit of the game. I wish I could bottle that feeling of one-ness when we're all walking to the stadium, smiling at strangers, giving a toot on the vuvus; making new friends, taking pics of each other, helping carry each others' small kids; chatting about the game. I don't know if this site allows links in their posts - but you will find some pics of the last two Bafana matches on my flickr - my name is ethekwinigirl.
  • Thank you Karen. I founded Ubuntu Now and we started this project. But I've never been to a game in South Africa. So I really can't make any qualified statements.

    Bur I've met many African men over the last few years and I know how excited they are. I was amazed by the atmosphere in Korea in 2002 with all these people dressed in red in the stadium.

    2006 was equally exciting. I was in Germany during the final. Soccer has the power to unite and bring people together.

    I am pretty convinced we'll see amazing pictures and here many amazing stories this summer as well.

    We are here to promote tolerance and open mindedness towards each other and won't go away :)

    PS:
    We do allow links. Your images are amazing. Would you be willing to share some of your images at our FB fan page? You could upload them or I'd do so with your permission. Of course you get full credit. This is exactly what we would like to share within our community.
  • mike999999
    The soccer wold cup in sa should be BANNED!!!!
  • I understand that you were triggered by some other comments related to this blog post.

    Who "deserves" the World Cup and who doesn't? What are your expectations and based on what?

    Maybe there is more than one way to look at who deserves the World Cup?
    Did the US as a non-soccer nation deserve the World Cup?
    Did Germany deserve to host it twice within 32 years?

    South Africa is facing many big challenges. Many people in the country are not happy with the World Cup.

    But the balls will be kicked around down there this summer. Shouldn't we be open minded and just let them run the show and talk about the event afterwards?

    If you see the amount of pride and excitement in the faces of so many African (not just South African) men you might change your mind.

    Based on their enthusiasm for the sport they deserve being the host in my humble opinion.

    Peace.
  • didimatso
    thank you for understanding....I don't know why south africa have to prove itself so much to people who obviously hope that WC comes a disaster. either way, I'll go to matches & have myself a damn good time.

    & as for you mike, you know nothing about S.A. so keep your small mouth shut!!!!!!!WC will go on with or without you & every 1 that will be there will have themselves a good time. you don't have a perfect country either........
  • mike999999
    The soccer wold cup should be banned from SA as they don't deserve it!!!!!!!!
  • didi
    Vuvuzela this vuvuzela that, who cares, whether you people like or not the vuvuz will be there & i am gonna meke sure that I blow mine as loud as I can just to irritate the S@$#T out of you. I am just sick & tired of this nagging & you jnow what? no 1 cares, the fact that world cup is in africa, we will do it our own way, so deal with it!!!!!!!. its easy, DO NOT COME if it bugs you so much.
  • Didi: This blog is a space where we show respect for each other and other's opinions. A language that triggers very harsh reactions from others is not serving our blog very well.

    We are here to agree to disagree in a polite manner.

    Yes this World Cup is in South Africa and it will have a different look and feel than any other world Cup before. I am looking forward to it. But South Africa is also host for the rest of the world. A good host tries to be accommodating and not simply say: "it is my way or the highway".

    People are worried about the Vuvuzela taking away the atmosphere fans in a stadium and spectators in TV are used to.

    If the noise becomes deafening and there is no more chanting the game will be a different experience. That's what many people are worried about.

    On the other hand I know how super super excited many people in South Africa and on the entire African continent are. You deserve this event.

    South Africa Project wouldn't even be here if we wouldn't believe in you guys.

    Let's practice some tolerance and make this a fun summer for everyone.
  • stephentheobald
    The constant drone of the vuvuzela will certainly cause me to mute the sound on my TV while watching the 2010 World Cup. When I learned that South Africa was confirmed as the host of the cup, I groaned out loud. Also, it appears that these noisemakers could easily be used as weapons during a crowd disturbance. Vigorous chanting is great, but even if the vuvuzela is a cultural tradition in South Africa, I object to allowing them into the venues.
  • leighlingling
    I think that if it wasn't a African country which was in this situation then no one would have complained about it.This was just another excuse for the World Cup not to land on the African soil or bloody hell make us look like Prematives!

    The Europeans have their way of celebrating and therefore why can't they accept our differences,this is just another prejudice act.

    WHO complains about their chanting and the majority of their blokes being drunk on the stands and another problem is them having nasty comments when African players are playing in the English Premier League.Ever thought why the FIFA Say No To Racism campaign results from??????????

    I'm doing an assignment and practical for Design about the issue and I'm glad I came accross this site to get the different views.

    I say OUR PRIDE,OUR INVENTION,OUR VUVUZELA

    "COME & CELEBRATE THE MAGIC OF AFRICA "
  • borislav
    Are you really think they can ban it? no way.
    Fans are buy-vuvuzela,com every day
  • Oh Come on - the Vuyvuzela is joyous - it uplifts the spirits of the fans and the players. It makes the soccer stadiums rock. And when you see the fans arrive, all dressed up in the regalia, clutching their vuvus you know that they are ready for serious football. South African soccer fans are passionate about the beautiful game ... and about their vuvuzelas.
  • Jeremy
    South African fans are saying the rest of the world (not just Europe) isn't respecting their football culture.

    Well, let's say Brazil are playing against France in the 2010 World Cup. The Brazilian supporters will be chanting "Brasil! Brasil!" to the beat of the samba drums & creating a carnival; the French will be singing "La Marseillaise" & "Allez les Bleus".

    BUT unfortunately, both groups of supporters will be totally & continually drowned (and droned) out by this: "BUZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ".

    WHO is being disrespectful?
  • mike999999
    They don't have a football culture!
  • D Matheson
    Sett Blatter is right, FIFA oughtn't try to Europeanise an African World Cup. Having lived in S Africa, I know the excitement lent to the general atmosphere of a match when fans are allowed to express themselves with the stadium horns. The sound is synonymous with great football in that country. Keep the vuvuzela!!!
  • bootylover
    worst sound ever.
    bang a drum, learn a chant.
    dont blow a crappy kazoo just because you can.
    i hope there is never another world cup in africa as long
    as i live.
  • mike999999
    You have my support!
  • Fut Ball
    South African football has great songs that does not need the vuvuzela:

    http://www.footballiscominghome.net/video/the-v...
  • Kath
    KEEP THE VUVUZELA!! People will get used to the sound and apparently it's not so bad IN the stadium as on TV.. So what is the moral of the story? GET YOUR BUT DOWN TO SOUTH AFRICA AND WATCH THE GAME LIVE! Then you won't need to hear an incessant drone from your little speakers :)
  • jennyjenjen
    I'm going to argue this for the sake of making an argument -- but the vuvuzela is what keeps South African football... well, South African football. Why bring the World Cup to SA and turn it into a European game?

    Okay, yeah, I'm not fond of the sound. But banning them entirely? Aren't we taking away what South Africans really enjoy about the game?

    Can there be compromise?
  • mike999999
    It's noise and irritating!!!
  • Tuska
    The vuvuzela is so cool I want one when I come to SA for the world cup.
  • The problem is that the vuvuzelas level everything else out. There is no chanting, or feeling the regular change of emotions in the crowd with that constant noise. Unfortuantely not all of these guys are the next Hugh Masekelas. I'd opt for banning them. But now a certain culture has been established already and people will complain.
blog comments powered by Disqus

More Blog Post